Library Assessment Project
Developed by Annette Vanderwall
CTER, University of Illinois


Assessment Development


Project Objectives

The New Lenox School District Libraries are currently undergoing curriculum changes.  Last year, the Information Specialists and Librarians from each of the nine schools met to redesign the library curriculum to help benefit all of the students in the New Lenox School District.  The curriculum changes are now complete and the curriculum is in the process of being adopted by the schools in the surrounding communities.  The missing piece to curriculum is the assessments.  Currently, there are no assessments at the primary level to provide any feedback to the success or failure of the newly adopted curriculum.

This course will provide the opportunity for me to develop a series of assessments that will help the primary library teachers with a way to measure the effectiveness of the library curriculum.  There are nine standards that the library curriculum is expected to meet each year. In this project I would like to focus on developing assessments for two of the standards that are vital to helping the primary students become successful in school and in life. The assessments will be developed for the third grade students. The assessments will be a combination of formal and informal evaluations that will show measurable growth in the students in a set amount of time.

K
W
L
Standard 1: The students who is information literate accesses information efficiently and effectively.

The students are provided opportunities to learn and identify different types of resource such as fiction and non-fiction and how they are organized, using a computerized catalog, and looking for information in books.

Students have the skills to look up information, they are able to answer questions in class, but they cannot transfer this knowledge outside of class or even during open library time.

How can the students successfully transfer the knowledge they are learning outside of class?

What type of assessment would benefit the students in this situation?

The students never have to find the material on their own.  There is always someone to show them the books or where to look.  Requiring the children to use the card catalog or locate the call number will allow the students to transfer their knowledge and gain confidence in their skills

A performance assessment seemed to be the best assessment for the time frame and limited paper resources available in the school.



Standard 6:
The student who is an independent learner is information literate and strives for excellence in information seeking and knowledge generation.

Students are given the skills use a card catalog, and locate books of a shelf on a weekly or daily basis based on individual use of the library.

Why can’t children locate a book of a shelf???  How can children become more confident and independent in their own abilities to locate information and materials?

Can observation be the only form of assessment?  Would a rubric be of any benefit to the children in this case?

I have learned that the best way to get students to transfer knowledge is to have them actually perform the task.  You can talk to students and simulate situations, but it is not until the students actually are responsible for locating the books or identifying the parts of a book that they truly understand.

While observation is a great way to see if the students are able to understand, I found that performance assessments along with observations worked out well in seeing if the students are able to transfer their skills.

I designed a very simple rubric for each of the assessments and found that they were very helpful when scoring the students work.  It helped me stay consistent in my scoring of the students work.


..............................



Curriculum Map


This project was developed for the
590 ASA Alternative Student Assessment Course
Instructor
Dr. Kathrine Ryan
CTER 6 Program
University of Illinois
Urbana Champaign
Spring 2005